Patrick Harvie of Standish, Maine, doing business as HCCI in Derry, NH, has received $2,281.25 from Tuftonboro taxpayers in exchange for his “expert” testimony last month about “metadata” at the hearing for the selectmen’s lawsuit against Bob McWhirter and me (Tuftonboro vs McWhirter/Ledoux). The selectmen sued us because we made Right to Know requests for public documents.
The legal fees that taxpayers of Tuftonboro have paid to the selectmen’s attorney, Rick Sager of Ossipee, for this case currently total $16,336.12. Harvie’s payment, made on July 11, brings the total amount of taxpayer money expended by the selectmen in their lawsuit to at least 18,617.37.
The selectmen tried to charge Bob and me a fee to inspect governmental records, even though the Right to Know law (91-A) states, “No fee shall be charged for the inspection or delivery, without copying, of governmental records, whether in paper, electronic, or other form.”
The amount the selectmen tried to charge me to inspect documents was $6.50. They have spent nearly 3,000* times more than that so far on this lawsuit.
When prompted by Sager in court, Harvie boasted under oath that he knows “just about everything about how the internet works.” Even so, Judge Amy Ignatius rebuked him for using a monitor that she could not see. “Can I ask, since I can’t see any of it — I know there’s something up on the screen, but it’s not readable from here. …For my sake, and the sake of the record, if you want to point something out, a phrase like, ‘as you can see,’ doesn’t do much for me because I can’t see anything. So you need to really explain what it is.”
Harvie’s testimony was further made irrelevant when Jim Cowles, representing Bob and me, objected to his testimony on the grounds that neither Bob nor I had requested any metadata and did not contest that metadata exists. Judge Ignatius agreed that the testimony about whether metadata exists was unnecessary and asked that Sager move on. Seeming flustered, Sager then said, “Yes. K. So, uh, I guess your presentation is over.”
*The total they have spent is $18,617.37. What they wanted to charge me was $6.50. 2,864.21 * $6.50 = $18,617.37.